Phrase “How to Thank in Sindarin” by Elaran

This is great! It got me really thinking.

Great job ! Wish I had this level of mastery in Tolkien languages lore.

Is this Annon mutated somehow from Hanna-? I wish I knew why this phrase was better.

Did you read the article? The reasoning is outlined in a fair amount of detail.

In fact I did not put 2 and 2 together that there was an article and now I shall dredge it up.

Click here for the article.

I had to read that several times to make sense of it, but I think I understand. Hanta-> Hanna-> anna- which is valid to use because the old form of anna- has been replaced. It is very interesting! Annon Allen!

So, if annon allen is "I give thanks to you", is annon atin "I give thanks to them"?

The dative pronouns for Sindarin are still unclear, but currently the linguistic community uses either ethin or athin for "to/for them". I personally prefer ethin.

So, annon athin?

Either that or annon ethin, yes.