Carnimírië vs Carnemírië

david wendelken #4799

I've seen references to both.

Are both valid choices for Quenya, particularly Vanyarin Quenya?

Ellanto #4800

Carnemírie appeared in the 1st edition of LotR, and Tolkien changed it to Carnimírie in the 2nd edition, so I do not think both are valid.

Based on what little we know of Vanyarin, I see no reason why it would differ on this point.

david wendelken #4801

Thanks! That explains my confusion.